The Bio-Politic: Markets in Biology, Bodies, and Information

Economic historian Karl Polanyi has a name for things not originally produced for sale on the market: he called them “fictitious” commodities. In this category he included land and labor. Polanyi argued that at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, when these factors of production became organized as commodities to be bought and sold on the market, human history entered a radically new chapter in which pride of place was given to the market as the basis for the whole organization of society. “The Great Transformation,” as he called it, meant “no less than the running of society as an adjunct to the market.”

Today, the free-market ethos pinpointed by Polanyi continues its creep into the fundamental elements of life—or what the Greeks called bios, whether in the form of people, body parts, biological and genetic matter or information thereof—generating a new catalogue of fictitious commodities. In our brave new world, not only is human activity (labor) available on the market, human bodies and body parts, too, are “things” subject to exchange. And nature—or “land” in Polanyi’s designation—is also up for sale. But today’s coveted “real estate” is the biological matter of the natural world and its genetic components. These natural resources can be accumulated and hoarded as intellectual property patents and other forms of privileged information. In fact, with the technological leaps and bounds of recent decades, information itself is not only being controlled for profit, it is also being leveraged to preserve discriminatory social orders. This Report traces some of these disturbing trends.

March/April
2006
Volume: 
39
Number: 
1

Taking Note

Teo Ballvé
As the tri-colored presidential sash was draped over the shoulder of Evo Morales on January 22, tears welled up in his eyes. The day before, he was vested with the power to rule by amautas (indigenous authorities) at the pre-Incan ruins of Tiwanaku, where a crowd of some 50,000 cheered the nation’s new Aymara president; history in the making.

Intro

NACLA
Economic historian Karl Polanyi had a name for things not originally produced for sale on the market: he called them “fictitious” commodities. In this category he included land and labor.

Updates

Teo Ballvé
“We did not come here to invite you to die or to kill; instead we came here to invite you to live—to live by fighting—but no longer alone, apart from each other. That way, there won’t have to be another January 1, 1994, and no one else will ever have to cover their face in order to be seen.” With these words, Subcomandante Marcos on January 14 addressed a crowd of about 700 people in the city of Chetumal, the state capital of Quintana Roo.
Renata Rendón
The following account is based on a series of diary entries, interviews and personal recollections about the events of February 2005 in the Peace Community of San José de Apartadó, Colombia.

Report

Kelly Gates
The July 2000 elections in Mexico were historic for more reasons than the defeat of decades-long one-party rule. In a move ostensibly aimed at eliminating duplicate voter registrations and curbing electoral fraud, the country’s Federal Electoral Institute (IFE) contracted with MetaData, a Mexico City–based software integrator, and Visionics Corporation, a leading U.S. vendor of biometric identification technologies, to incorporate the Visionics FaceIt automated facial recognition system into the voter registration process.
Nancy Scheper-Hughes
Stephen Frears’ film Dirty Pretty Things treats the traffic in human frailty and vulnerability in the shadowy underworld of immigrant London. In one poignant scene, Okwe, a politically framed, sleepless, haunted Nigerian doctor-refugee, hiding out as a hotel receptionist, delivers a freshly purloined human kidney in a Styrofoam cooler to a sleazy body-parts broker waiting in the underground parking lot of the hotel.
Cori Hayden
Bioprospecting is a relatively new name for a well-established practice. The term was coined by sustainable development advocates in the late 1980s to refer to the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries’ renewed interest in the use of plants, microbes and “traditional knowledge” as leads for developing new products.
Sonia Shah
Just as automakers and apparel manufacturers have fled the stringent labor and environmental laws of developed countries to set up shop in the developing world, pharmaceutical companies have streamed across the border in pursuit of warm bodies for the testing of new experimental drugs.
Michael K. Dorsey
More than a decade ago, the authors of the once-groundbreaking book Biodiversity Prospecting argued that lifesaving drugs from genetic and biochemical resources, primarily from tropical rainforests, could be a positive force for development and conservation.
Amy Bracken
“After 200 years of bees, let’s have 200 years of honey.” So proposed a T-shirt issued by the Haitian government at the end of 2003 to celebrate the impending bicentennial of independence and freedom from slavery. But with no honey in sight, there wasn’t much to celebrate, as anti-government violence coupled with a dismal economy stifled any potential revelry.

Reviews

David Graeber
If you set out to write a book on Zapatista solidarity networks, there are two obvious stories you could tell. One is about a relatively small band of mostly indigenous rebels in Mexico who launched a brief uprising against the Mexican government in 1994.

Letters

Luis Rumbaut
In “Cuba: New Partners and Old Limits” [September/October 2005, “Empire and Dissent”] Daniela Spenser calls for Cuba to devolve into a happy camp of autonomous NGOs connected to the Internet.

In Brief

Alex van Schaick
On January 3, after years of an openly hostile relationship with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Argentina cleared its entire $9.81 billion debt with the multilateral financial institution. Announcing the decision last December, President Néstor Kirchner, said the payment “will allow us to build a more just future, with greater flexibility in the design and implementation of economic policies.”

¡YA! Youth Activism

Suzanne MacNeil
Every June 30, the Guatemalan military parades down the streets of Guatemala City in full pomp and splendor to commemorate “Army Day.” The parade celebrates the Army’s role in society and is devoid of any acknowledgement of the atrocities committed by the military and its proxies over the course of the country’s 36-year civil war, during which more than 200,000 Guatemalans—most of them Maya indigenous—were killed and 44,000 disappeared.