Who Owns Knowledge? BioBattles and TechnoStrife in Latin America

Who owns knowledge? Who owns science? At first glance, the questions seem ridiculous: How can anyone own the store of facts about the world and ways of doing things that people, individually and collectively, keep in their heads? It turns out that what we really mean when we ask this question is "who will have the right to control the circulation of knowledge?" and, even more importantly, "who will have the right to benefit from it?" Answering this question takes us into the seemingly arcane realm of copyright and patent law and what has come to be called "intellectual property." But, as the contributors to this issue of the NACLA Report show, questions of "intellectual property" have very real effects.

March/April
2002
Volume: 
35
Number: 
5

Taking Note

Fred Rosen
The subtitle of Andrés Gaudin’s report from Argentina ["Thirteen Days that Shook Argentina," p. 6] fairly shouts at us: "And Now What?" The good news from that troubled country is that its military, which not so long ago presided over one of the more brutal dictatorships of the many that have plagued South America, seems content to watch this financial and political crisis from the sidelines.

Intro

JoAnn Kawell
In Latin the word scientia means "knowledge––and our word "science" means, at base, "systems of knowledge" and "ways we come to know things."

Updates

Adam Isacson
As we went to press, the Colombian peace process discussed here broke down again, this time seemingly irreparably. On February 20, after FARC guerrillas highjacked an airplane and kidnapped a Colombian senator, President Andrés Pastrana declared talks with the FARC over.
Andrés Gaudin
December 2001 marked a turning point for Argentina. First the government did violence to society by putting strict limits on the way people could use their money and the forms in which they could use it.

Report

Barbara Belejack
The road from the airport at Tuxtla Gutiérrez to San Cristóbal in Chiapas, Mexico wends its way from balmy tropics to cloud covered mountains; a remarkable diversity of topography and climate for a drive of less than two hours. Those extremes of climate and topography make Chiapas rich in plant biodiversity.
Amina Aitsiselme
Beginning in the early 1960s, biotechnology and medical research became a top priority of the Cuban government, which invested over one billion dollars in biotech research and development (R&D) in the 1990s alone. Cuba’s national Center for Scientific Investigation was founded in 1965, leading the way for the opening of numerous other research facilities.
Carlos Passarelli and Veriano Terto Jr.
Brazil is often singled out as an outstanding example of a developing nation with a successful program to slow the spread of AIDS. At the end of the 1980s, when Ziduvodine (AZT) was the only available treatment for people with AIDS, it was predicted that more than a million Brazilians would be infected with HIV by now, yet the most pessimistic current estimate indicates only slightly more than half that number, some 537,000, are infected, with some 210,000 classified as AIDS cases by the ministry of health.[1]
Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra and Marcos Cueto
Until recently, Latin American science has been dismissed as the underdeveloped and dependent poor cousin of science in the developed world.[1] But Latin American scientists have long made important contributions, and the history of science in Latin America provides a sharp lens for viewing the history of the region’s relations with the rest of world.
Wendy Call
The British came to southern Mexico nearly a century ago to build the railroad that slices across Oaxaca’s Tehuantepec Isthmus connecting the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, which are separated by less than 200 miles at this point.
Guillermo Delgado-P.
"A future with traditions," was the slogan the indigenous movement popularized during the 1992 Quincentennial, the 500th anniversary of Europe’s discovery of the Americas.
Charles L. Briggs & Clara Mantini-Briggs
In 1992 and 1993 some five hundred people died in the maze of rivers and thousands of large and small islands that form the delta region of the Orinoco River in eastern Venezuela. The disease that killed so many so quickly was cholera. One of us, Charles, stumbled onto the epidemic in November 1992 during a two-week visit to Tucupita, a city of some 40 thousand inhabitants and the capital of Delta Amacuro state.

Interview

JoAnn Kawell
Among the forms of knowledge—sciences—developed in the Americas before the arrival of the Europeans were sophisticated agricultural systems. The Incas, the Mayas and the Aztecs all developed systems capable of feeding large and concentrated populations.

In Brief

George Ann Potter, Latinamerica Press
A spiral of violence that began in mid-January in Bolivia’s coca-growing Chapare region and spread across the country leaving at least nine dead, was at least temporarily braked on February 9 when the government agreed to reverse several actions which had sparked the initial Chapare confrontation.