Crisis And Change: Colombia And Brazil

In this NACLA Report we look closely at two nations—Colombia and Brazil—that seem to be on very different trajectories as we head deeper into the 21st century. In Colombia, a four-decade-old civil war is on the verge of becoming bloodier and the country's deep-rooted social problems are further from solution than ever, while in Brazil new president Lula da Silva has raised hopes that he will be able to spark some real social and economic progress. It is not our intent here to draw explicit comparisons, but rather to examine the current state-of-affairs in these two Latin American A countries as a means of glimpsing some of the best and the worst that the region's future may hold.

March/April
2003
Volume: 
36
Number: 
5

Taking Note

Terry Gibbs
“Another world is not only possible, she is on her way. On a quiet day, I can hear her breathing.”—Arundhati Roy at the World Social Forum, Porto Alegre, Brazil.

Intro

JoAnn Kawell
In this NACLA Report we look closely at two nations—Colombia and Brazil—that seem to be on very different trajectories as we head deeper into the 21st century.

Updates

Wendy Call
Imagine this: Congressional representatives scramble out of their seats, ignoring their leader’s exhortations to remain calm. They sprint out the back door of the building, trying to jump the fence that surrounds their meeting place.

Report

Caros Amigos Magazine
Brazilian economist Celso Furtado, now 82 years old, was one of Latin America’s most influential economic and social thinkers during the last half of the 20th century. As one of the leading “underdevelopment” theorists connected with the UN Economic Commission on Latin America, he helped develop and promote Import Substitution Industrialization.
Hilary Wainwright
From the time it was founded in the early 1980s, the Brazilian Workers’ Party (PT) has maintained that electoral success is not an end in itself but a springboard for developing radical, participatory forms of democracy that will enable the country to start redressing the enormous inequalities in Brazilian society.
Sue Brandford
“We will carry out an ambitious program of agrarian reform that will make land available to thousands and thousands of excluded Brazilians so that they can pull themselves out of grinding poverty, become family farmers and have a decent standard of life,” said Miguel Rossetto to thunderous applause, as he took office as Minister of Agrarian Reform in January.
Sue Brandford & Jan Rocha
“I was born in Redentor near Tenente Portela in the north of Rio Grande do Sul state. My father farmed a small plot of land. I was only two and a half when my mother died in childbirth.
Sean Sweeney
Last December, when then President-elect Lula da Silva met with the Executive Council of the AFL-CIO in a celebratory gathering in Washington D.C., Federation President John Sweeney said, “It’s a pleasure to have a president we can all call brother here today” and pledged that the U.S. union movement and workers “will stand side by side” with Lula in his struggle to solve Brazil’s serious economic and social problems.
Garry M.Leech
Saravena, Colombia—Boom! Welcome to Saravena, known locally as “Little Sarajevo.” On February 5, the day after my arrival in this remote town of 30,000 people in Arauca department, I was awakened at 6 a.m. by an explosion.
Adam Isacson
In 1997—back when there was no such thing as a “war on terror” and George W. Bush was just a Texas governor on the make—U.S. aid for Colombia rose to a previously unheard-of level, $88.5 million.
Stanley Gacek
On October 27, 2002, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva—lathe operator, metalworker, undisputed leader of the independent labor movement that emerged in the late 1970’s to challenge the military regime, founder of the Brazilian Workers’ Party (PT) and a former congressman representing the state of São Paulo—was elected president of the largest and most strategic power in Latin America, the world’s fifth-largest nation in population, and one of the ten largest economies on the globe.

Reviews

Winifred Tate
Human Rights Watch researcher Robin Kirk says her intention in More Terrible Than Death: Massacres, Drugs and America’s War in Colombia is “to tell stories,” the complicated, emotional and contradictory stories excluded from the legal-document format of human rights reports.

In Brief

Teo Ballvé
The U.S. Navy has ended practice bombing on the Puerto Rican Island of Vieques after 56 years and three decades of protest. Operations conducted in the ocean near Vieques, however, will continue, and plans are underway to use various new locations—mostly in the southeastern United States—to make up for the loss of Vieques.

Article

HW
It is impossible to understand the participatory methods of the lrazilian Workers' Party (PT) without recognizing the important contribution made by educator Paulo Freire. A supporter of the PT until he died in 1997, Freire saw edu- cation as a transformative tool that could create experiences of a truly equal and democratic nature, which people would then be inspired to reproduce.